3-Client Preview · Locked Baseline v1

Generated 2026-05-19 · Recipe: baseline-89 (OD web-prototype · codex · default prompt) · SOP: docs/v3/SOP-LOCKED-BASELINE-V1.md

Context: After 11 OD experiments on vicwest today, baseline 89 is the only stable multi-page recipe. vip + wc YELLOW path uses pl:data-checkpoint + pl:llm-infer-thin-data + pl:build-od-seed (auto-merges inferred data). Agent IGNORED the YELLOW single-page + preview-banner directives — produced multi-page anyway. Cross-page chrome inconsistency (header 乱跳) is a known v1 limit · pending v2.

GREEN

Vicwest Roofing

Ballarat VIC · metal roofing

Pages	10 (+ brand preview)
Total HTML	290 KB
Hayden mentions	31
VBA mentions	37
Real testimonials	5 (verbatim)
Data verdict	GREEN · all verified

Open site →

YELLOW

VIP Roofing Brisbane

Brisbane QLD · roofing contractor

Pages	9
Total HTML	220 KB
Brisbane mentions	175
Phone verbatim	77 instances
Inferred fields	6 (suburbs/services/testimonials/owner/experience/ABN)
Data verdict	YELLOW · 0/6 rich verified

Open site →

YELLOW

West Coast Roofing

Geelong VIC · since 1982 · tile + metal

Pages	5
Total HTML	48 KB
West Coast mentions	22
1982 mentions	4
Inferred fields	3 (testimonials/owner/ABN)
Data verdict	YELLOW · 3/6 rich verified

Open site →

Observations

vicwest 10 pages — proven baseline (89 audit · 290 KB · richest data dossier)
vip 9 pages — best YELLOW outcome today · uniform 23KB density
wc 5 pages — index rich (29KB) · inner pages thin (4-5KB) — variance signal
Agent ignored YELLOW single-page directive — produced multi-page when data was rich enough
Agent ignored MANDATORY preview banner directive — 0 banners
Agent ignored shared chrome directive — header still varies per page

Known v1 limits (deferred to v2)

±10-point variance between same-recipe runs
Cross-page chrome inconsistency (every page has different header bytes)
YELLOW preview banner not enforced
AI-fabricated testimonials sometimes skipped by agent